I’ve seen a lot of charts that try to sort cuckolds into types. They don’t even agree on what they’re sorting.
Some go by how a man feels about it. Some go by whether he watches, waits in the other room, or joins in. Some go by who is submissive to whom. Same word, different boxes.
I didn’t know what a cuckold was when this started for me. I’d never even heard the word. I joined in that first night. The next morning, I felt embarrassment that excited me, and I felt more in love with her. A few days later, when I saw she had romantic feelings for him, it hurt, and I got up and left.
(The full story is in Married at 17: How It Started.)
That’s already more than one box, and it was the first week.
From an insult to a chosen identity
The word is older than most people think. It comes from the cuckoo bird, the one that lays its eggs in other birds’ nests and lets them do the raising. In English it goes back to the 1200s, and for most of that time it was not a lifestyle. It was an insult. It meant a man whose wife had been unfaithful, often without him knowing. Some lists still call that the unknowing cuckold.
The idea shows up in more than one language. In a lot of Europe, people said a man in that position was wearing the horns. In China, they still talk about wearing a green hat. In Arabic, the word is dayyuth, for a man seen as letting it happen in his household.
What’s different now is that the man knows, and he chooses it. The way many of us use the word today is not the same as being cheated on. It’s something a couple talks about and agrees to.
That doesn’t mean every man who has these feelings is cheering it on. It doesn’t mean it always feels simple. It just means the old insult and the life some of us live are not the same thing.
There’s an old word for when a woman is in that role, too: cuckquean. It goes back to the 1500s. This isn’t only a men’s story.
Watching, waiting, or joining in
If you set the labels aside and look at what people actually do, a lot of the lists are really sorting by how involved the man is.
Some men watch. They’re in the room, or close enough to see. The night is happening in front of them, and being there is the point.
Some men wait. They’re in another room, down the hall, or at home while she is out. They know what’s going on, or they hear about it after. Her going on vacation, or going out for the night, often lands in this same group. The involvement is in the knowing, the waiting, and whatever they share when she comes back.
Some men join in. They’re part of the night, not off to the side. That’s how my first night went.
That’s often just called a threesome. Some charts split a regular threesome from a cuckold threesome, depending on whether the focus stays on all three of you or on her with the other man. I don’t spend a lot of time on that difference. A night can lean one way or the other, or both.
Beyond those three, it gets more specific. Group nights. A third person they met for the occasion. The man also being involved with the other man. Those are still mostly about who is in the room and how close he is to what’s happening. They’re variations, not a new kind of person.
Besides that first night, I’ve joined in a few times, and in the beginning I would watch. I enjoyed watching, but I also felt more comfortable being there for her safety if it was someone we didn’t know very well. As for group nights, I watched one, participated in one, and wasn’t there for the other two. Most of the time, I waited at home or was at work while my wife at the time met a friend.
The flavor
The other way people try to sort this is by what it feels like.
For some men, the main feeling is being happy because she’s happy. Some people call that compersion. Wanting her happy, and being the one she shared it all with, turned out to matter more than being the only one.
For some, it’s service. The pleasure is in making it possible for her, taking care of her, being useful to her before and after.
For some, it’s submission. They like being in a less powerful role, with her, or with the other man, or both. One chart even includes a couple who are both submissive to the third person.
For some, humiliation is the charge. The embarrassment is not an accident. It’s part of what does it for them. I think humiliation is present in varying degrees.
Some men are running more on pride than on surrender. They’re proud she is desired, proud to share her, and they don’t feel small about it. That’s often called a stag, or filed under hotwife. Others treat hotwife as a type of cuckold, and stag as a point on the same line. People argue about those words a lot. I’m not here to say one beats the other. She’s with another man, and he’s involved somehow. Past that, the flavor is personal.
For me, it’s compersion and pride. I have very little experience with humiliation and no experience with submission, but I fantasize about both.
Some charts also include a dominant husband, or a man who is more drawn to the other role, the one usually called the bull. Not everyone who is interested in this is coming from a submissive place, and not everyone wants to sit in the same seat.
You don’t have to fit a chart
I could check half the boxes on any of those lists and leave the other half blank. So could a lot of people.
The charts are just people trying to describe their own version and giving it a name. That’s fine, until the name starts feeling like a test you can fail.
If the lists can’t agree with each other, I’m not going to lose sleep over which one I belong on. The feelings can be mixed. I liked it and I got hurt. I felt more in love and I got up and left. None of that made it less real.
You don’t have to fit a chart. What has always mattered more, for me, is figuring out what we actually wanted, and sharing the experience.
